Things were looking pretty bleak for EverQuest Legends before the latest content drop. Once bustling rooms were standing empty; all the servers were listed as low population; Kasul and I, among EQL’s biggest fans, had moved on to other games.
Kasul wants me to explain: He only quit because he had unlocked all the races and all the classes, and had finished farming Fear for the Slime Blood of Cazic Thule, the best ALL/ALL gloves in the game. He adds: he didn’t really quit, he just hadn’t logged in for six days. He was playing Frosthaven Digital.
I was playing Dune: Awakening and Enshrouded. I “stopped playing” because there wasn’t anything I felt motivated to doing. I wanted to wait for Half Dark Elves to be released so I could start a new combo. They’re called Half Dark Elves, but I just shorten that down to Quarter Elves.
Anyway. We knew Game Jawn was working night and day to get the content drop out before Hallowe’en. We’d be getting the Eighth Elves, a new race that needs to be leveled up, just as with classes. If you unlocked Sixteenth Elves (via the lengthy but not difficult quest) and started a new loadout as one of them, you’d be starting at level 1, no matter what level the three chosen classes were at. Fortunately, you could start right off with three classes instead of the two that were available prior to level 10 as a new character. That new homeopathic elf also is restricted to the primary classes that you have unlocked.
Along with the new race comes a new starting city/newbie ground, Lake Nerius; a new collection of class trainers and merchants in the HDE hidden refuge, the Undercroft; and Nektropos Castle itself, home of the Everling family, who lost everything, and the one son who had no choice but to keep them all together. It’s EverQuest Legends.
The Ayr’Haeth
Half Dark Elves, whose official name means “Half Lesser”, are a mélange of human, elf, and dark elf ancestry. If half elves don’t feel welcome in either elf or human society, Ayr’Haeth aren’t welcome in any of those places either. And dark elves? Only the purest of bloods for them, thanks.. The only place that will have them is the wine cellar — the Undercroft — of Nektropos Castle, where they have thrived in secret, unbeknownst to the family living above.
I’d thought that “Half Dark Elves” would be the vampiric Freeblood from EverQuest 2, but these mixed peoples weren’t that lucky. No turning into bats or wolves for them. They have reduced health regeneration when outside during the day, but they do get extra benefit from lifetaps and runes, and they can sense the presence of the living from a great distance.
But they are definitely not Freeblood. Again, they don’t get the special bite attack. EQ2 Freeblood are awesome.
The Undercroft
This is the official home of the Ayr’Haeth — if one casts Origin, this is where they are transported. It’s a maze of wine casks, left here who knows how long ago. Every class trainer is here, except for (as far as I could tell) magician. There may be others, but this one stood out for me when I started a Half Dark Elf Rogue/Magician/Druid and could not find any magician spells. I had to take my new Half Dark Elf butt to Steamfont. Which was fine; I D4’d Steamfont and got a half dozen easy levels while I was there. Low level stuff is trivial when you have planar gear.
Lake Nerius
Lake Nerius is west of Nektulos Forest and is a suitably spooky meadow covered with low level bats, snakes and spiders, skeletons, and ghosts. I’m not sure where the ghosts come from, but I vaguely remember the area in EverQuest 2 had a bunch as well. The river is filled with piranha; the lake itself, with ghostly gillfish, and a nasty high level undead guppy lurking in the northeast corner of the lake. This is a key mob for the quest for the key to the castle. In the NW corner is a fisherman. In the NE corner of the zone is Nektropos Castle and the Undercroft. West of the Nektulos Forest zone is a collection of huts and ruins that provide services and vendors for the non-Ayr-Haeth visitors. It’s here that the quests start for the Nektropos Castle key, the Half Dark Elf racial unlock, and the Hallowe’en event (that rewards you with a pet illusion, in addition to the free one you get with the content drop).
The free pet illusion is a werewolf. You can choose among several others once you finish the quest; I chose Gelatinous Cube.
I was thrilled to see the Dire Bear that lived in the Nektropos Castle vicinity in EQ2 had accompanied the castle to EQ Legends. I still have the Dire Bear pewter mini that came with an EQ2 expansion, and starring whom I did a webcomic back in the day (Adventures in Monopoly).
Nektropos Castle
Game Jawn promised that they spared no expense in making Nektropos Castle as similar as they could to the EQ2 zone; you can overlay the maps of the EQL and EQ2 zones and they would more or less match up. Finding my way around was mostly a matter of trying to remember how I got around the place in EQ2, and more often than not, that would work in EQL.
Easier, actually, since areas were not blocked off by solving environmental puzzles. Everything opened either by key or plot; no finding places to fit boar eyes or chess pieces.
The loot in Nektropos Castle is generally pretty good and appropriate for the level; many pieces can find a place in your build even if you’ve spent time in the Planes and working on Sky quests. I believe I am using a range item, a ring, and a chest item from Lord Everling himself on my main Paladin/Monk/Enchanter combo; more items have found their way into my other combos.
The main story quest for the zone tells the story of corruption that spread through the castle, perhaps from Lord Everling’s laboratory, that started driving the castle staff insane. One servant, Plimptos, killed all seven of the daughters. He was immediately killed, but then was brought back to life, cursed to not die until his curse was lifted.
As he relates his sad tale, the demi-goddess Ulkorruuk speaks in our mind telling us that to remove his curse, we must put all seven daughters to rest (in EQ2, these daughters are really golems in the shape of the daughters; here, they are ghosts). Ulkorruuk is the demi-goddess of treason and insurrection, and we must meet with one of her priestesses in the Plane of Hate as part of the entrance quest.
But killing the seven daughters is not enough; we must also kill Lord Everling so that he cannot raise them back up again. Completing the quest grants a fairly decent one handed slashing sword with a semi-unique look (though not as unique as it looks in your inventory).
The Fights and the Controversy
Some players want all the fights in EverQuest Legends to be AFK-auto-attack tank and spank power fantasies. These people are all over the EQL Discord complaining that their preferred combo cannot complete all the content.
Other players want the fights to have lots of mechanics. These players will be pretty happy with what they find in the castle.
That’s not to say that there are no face tanking bosses in the zone; there are several. But the best stuff requires a little more thought.
I’m just going to spoil one of them, but it’s the biggest one — Lord Rikantus Everling.
Everling pretends to be a necromancer, but that’s just to have you underestimate him. He will hurt you.
Tanking Lord Everling solo is hard enough; he can crit for over a thousand damage just by poking you with his staff. Not to mention all the spell hurt he lays down. At 90% and every 20% thereafter, he will summon a Guardian Golem to pummel you. At 80% and every 20% thereafter, he summons a horde of untargetable, unkillable zombies (that despawn when you pass a threshold). If a Guardian Golem is still alive when the 10% threshold is hit, the room fills with zombies.
Nuking Everling down will fill the room with hurt.
The secret is to root and snare Everling and kill him until the golem spawns. You then drag the golem away and kill it (or charm it and send it to Everling for him to kill, as he has 95% damage resistance while the golem is alive). Then burn it through the zombie spawn until the next golem, rinse and repeat. Need a rest? Just keep Everling rooted during one of the breaks between spawns and heal, rest, etc. After the last golem is dead, burn him down.
Kasul and I did this for all difficulties from D0 through to D4 just to see if we could. Yup, we could — though Everling hit very very hard at the higher difficulties. I tanked with evasive stance toward the end.
As a duo, it was easy. But my combo couldn’t do it alone; I don’t have a snare in my combo, and my root is prone to breaking. (There may be an AA for that; I’ll have to look). I only have one DoT and my ranged options are not great.
I figure I could do it if I changed to a Paladin/Druid/Enchanter combo, though. Druid brings better roots, snares, DoTs and nukes. Enchanter, buffs and slows. Paladin, armor and other buffs.
But, I’m totally out of luck with my current combo. My Warrior/Cleric/Enchanter combo didn’t work any better — gotta have that snare or he will always be in your face. My Shadow Knight/Berserker/Shaman combo probably could do it, but that combo is only level 33; I’d have to level it up.
Everling’s fight is the hardest, but it illustrates how Game Jawn is building encounters now. Soloable, yes. Is it soloable with every combo? No. Can you ignore the mechanics? Maybe, sometimes, but if you’re playing at the highest difficulties, probably not. To GJ’s credit, the mechanics are not that hard to figure out, once you’ve died to them once or twice. C’rate, the named mimic in the cellar, will feed on you, instantly killing you, unless you interrupt the feeding or move out of mouth range. The Game Master will flip the gaming table on top of you and pelt you with billiard balls from the other side of the room. The Head Librarian is dealing with cursed books — and so on.
The loot is good enough to get people logging in to farm. Grouping makes mechanics easy enough that I would expect duos to have a real advantage. Having the new race start at level 1 is a kind of poor man’s reincarnation, requiring one more trip through the levels.
Is it enough?
I hope so. I really, really want to see what the team has in store. I think the current direction is amazing; we were not seeing this level of boss fighting in classic EverQuest until Velious, and there it was definitely not soloable.
With WoW Forever on the horizon, and the game already facing an exodus of players, I don’t know how many people will still be playing to adventure in the Rulers of Kunark expansion. But, maybe the lure of Kunark will bring people back.
This is the content they should focus on, though — this is the new stuff that I want to see. A Permafrost revamp, as with the recent Mistmoore revamp, is a welcome addition for the people already playing, but they won’t get anyone new to subscribe or log in with just revamps of existing zones. Content like Nektropos Castle and the Rulers of Kunark, will.








Hmm. From the outside, it sounds as though GameJawn are repeating the exact same cycle that drove people away from EverQuest to WoW and that later turned WoW from a mainstream success to a niche game, albeit a very large niche. The USP of EQL, the philosophy that appeared to fuel all the pre-release promotional drive and which, more importantly, was how it was interpreted by the gaming media, was Classic EQ but you can solo everything. That was the core offer with continual development of different content to OG EQ as the added value.
I don’t see how they go from there, successfully, to very high level content with a difficulty pitched to be soloable by only the most skilled players, with everyone else needing to group for it. Being able to solo everything and never having to group was the whole point to a lot of people, I’d guess, and quite probably to most people who bought the game.
They are in a bit of a cleft stick, I’d say, and it was widely predicted. They probably don’t have the resources to roll out expansion after expansion at the speed they’d need to if they were going to keep everyone who bought the game engaged. I’d guess they’d need to bring a new expansion on line no slower than once a quarter. They’d need all of it to be soloable, of course. If they could do that, they’d have a rollout that would last them eight years, although it’s highly likely they’d lose any nostalgia factor about two years in.
I think that would keep a lot of people engaged but since they clearly can’t do it, they’re stuck with what they are doing, which looks to be a real expansion maybe every 6-9 months and some new content when they can get it done. Except the new content has to appeal to the people who haven’t left and that, as it always is in MMORPGs, will be the hardcore. Catering to the hardcore always alienates the general players – not just the casuals but anyone who doesn’t take the game extremely seriously – and the population goes into a declining spiral as the game effectively feeds on itself, catering for a smaller and smaller subsection and becoming more and more specialised.
If that bottoms out with a commercially viable population still in place, then there’s a sustainable, niche game that can carry on indefinitely. Almost all MMORPGs seem to end up there. It used to take years, though. Now it seems to take months and most games don’t get a sustainable population that way. How GameJawn are going to thread that needle is going to be interesting to watch from the outside but I’m very glad I didn’t buy the game and I’m feeling more and more sure as time goes on that I never will.
I don’t think that GameJawn ever said that they were just retooling EQ to be solo-able. This was “The Hero’s Journey” raison d’être, but GJ has been fairly clear that they are building a new EQ experience on the bones of the original game. That said, it’s super clear that there is a large segment of the playerbase that, yes, just wants the original content, solo-able, up through the Planes of Power.
I believe all of this content is already solo-able in the actual EQ game, if you have a max level character with the tens of thousands of AA points each character must earn to be viable. So if that’s all anyone wants, well, it’s available.
What really kills EQL is that it is a separate subscription from EverQuest. The main audience for EQL are current or returning EQ players, after all. If they were part of the normal EQ sub, people would be dropping in all the time to see the new content when they were bored of the main game or the TLP servers.
Unfortunately, EQL is currently charging a MMO fee for a solo experience that can be entirely completed, even by the most casual player, in a couple of months. GameJawn wants to give you reasons to start from scratch and level up a new combo (or a new race/class combo) via a different path, hoping that you’ll make different choices leveling up.
But at the end, you’ll always end up farming the same planes, and doing the Sky quests — and if you saved the loot you got the first time, you probably don’t even need to do the planes again.
If they could drop a Nektropos Castle on us every quarter, with Kunark-sized expansions twice a year, then, as you say, I think they could be sustainable for a few years. There’s enough expansions to mine for content; I’m trying to remember the last expansion I actually played. I think it had to do with Brell and the Underfoot? That came out in 2009, so there’s *17* years of content I know nothing about.
All that content may be unavailable to GJ, however, since EQ had a massive character model rewrite for the Luclin expansion and a massive zone overhaul that started with the Prophecy of Ro expansion. Later expansions might have depended upon the new tech introduced previously, so EQL might be limited to assets up to Velious, plus whatever new content they can build from these parts.
People who are looking to solo all the way up to current EQ content are almost certainly going to be out of luck with EverQuest Legends.